Humane's Ai Pin, a screenless wearable artificial intelligence device, was discontinued within roughly a year of its launch, after reviews found it slow, unreliable and unable to do the things a phone already did better, according to Reuters.

The failure is a case study in a specific kind of product mistake: building a new device category to solve a problem the dominant device already solves. The phone is a capable AI surface, a capable camera and a capable communicator, and a device that removes the screen to deliver those things via voice has to be dramatically better at each to justify the loss of the screen.

What the failure teaches

The lesson is not that wearable AI cannot work; it is that a new hardware category has to offer a use case the existing category cannot, and it has to do so on the first product. Humane raised on the strength of its founders and a vision of a post-phone future, and the market's verdict was that the future it described was not the one its product delivered. The company sold to HP for a fraction of its funding, and the pin is the cautionary example the next hardware founder will be asked to distinguish themselves from.