The decision between remote, hybrid and in-person work is, in most companies, treated as a real-estate decision and is, in all companies, a decision about the culture and operating model, and the leaders who treated it as the first got the wrong answer, and the ones who treated it as the second got a better one.
What the decision actually is
The decision determines how the company makes decisions, how it onboards, how it builds trust and how it resolves disagreement. A company that decides remotely makes decisions more slowly and writes them down more carefully. A company that decides in person makes decisions more quickly and relies on the context of the room. Each is a different operating system, and the choice between them is a choice about which system the company wants to run, not a choice about where the desks are.
What the leaders who got it right did
The leaders who got it right decided which kind of company they wanted to be and aligned the office policy with that, rather than surveying the workforce and splitting the difference. The companies that chose remote deliberately built the writing and the cadence that remote requires, and the ones that chose hybrid deliberately built the days-in-office that make the in-person time worthwhile. The companies that split the difference got the worst of both: a remote company without the remote discipline, and an in-person company without the in-person density.
